News comments suck

Heffernan muses on online news comments, which she calls a “bête noire for journalists and readers alike.” Turns out most comments on news stories aren’t intelligent. Who knew?

Commenters, in short, rarely really sock it to a columnist. They also too often go automatic, churning out 100-word synopses of one stock ideological position after another. But most disappointing of all, for readers, is that commenters don’t, as literary critics say, read an article against itself to show how, for example, an argument framed as incendiary is in fact banal, or one that’s meant to be feminist is retrogressive, or one that touts its originality is a knockoff.